The Human Condition and the Paradox of Crime and Conscience
Reflections on a Burglary and Society’s Complex Morality
Can you imagine a world where empathy and the potential for redemption lords over desperation and desolation? We must turn that vision into a collective reality.
Originally posted on my Medium account
![](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F789d252f-413d-4f74-80f4-9e7c9abb1035_597x702.jpeg)
Irecently came across a peculiar “meme” on Instagram that revolved around a story from 2013. It sent me spiraling down into a rabbit hole of thoughts and contemplation and I couldn’t help but share it with everyone here. On July 31, 2013, an event of crime and punishment took place that defies the usual narrative.
Apparently, a burglary took place in a common office building on said date, and the burglars who had stolen computers and other items experienced a change of heart and returned the items with a remorseful letter of apology:
“We had no idea what we were taking. Here’s your stuff back. We hope that you guys can continue to make a difference in people’s lives. God bless.”
This unusual story made me want to dig deeper into the broader societal implications of it and swim further into the depths of human mind. Why would such individuals choose to steal in the first place? And what could possibly drive them to return their loot at such great personal risk?
These questions demand a deeper exploration of morality, empathy, and the socio-economic pressures that shape our actions and reactions.
Desperation and Discontent
I think the act of stealing is very commonly stamped and dismissed as something inherently wrong done by the person. We often forget that theft stems from deeper societal and systemic problems like poverty, inequity, consumerism, and a survival instinct honed by years of hardship in a dog-eat-dog world.
I mean, in a society that idolizes material success, those who are haunted by a feeling of being left out, would see theft as their only path to attain a semblance of the wealth that they observe but cannot access. When the constant pressure to succeed clashes with a lack of opportunity, ethical boundaries are often smudged out by stories of self-explanations.
Just think about the life of a thief. Perhaps the person is buried under the mounds of debilitating debt, struggling to support a family, or simply trying to make ends meet. Life in a society that embellishes material wealth and possessions much more than it cares about morality, ethics, or personal virtues, is in deep peril of crumbling under its own weight. The allure of taking what one does not own becomes an enticing, albeit morally flawed, option.
But it’s more than just personal hardships. It’s about surviving in a society where people are robbed of their hope and dignity by institutionalized inequality. Large numbers of people become disenfranchised as a result of economic systems that concentrate money and power in the hands of a small number of people. Many are forced to make decisions by these frameworks that they might have not otherwise even thought of to make in different situations. Here, theft ceases to be a simple case of wrongdoing but rather becomes an indicator of a more serious social problem.
![](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff71f28cd-5bfa-4a72-badf-ff97dbd43d12_700x322.jpeg)
Moral Reckoning
Now let’s talk about the decision to return the stolen goods, accompanied by a sincere apology. For one, it speaks volumes about the burglars’ moral compass. It appears to be very obvious that once they realized whom they had robbed, they did not want to cause them any harm and moved to make amends for their wrongdoing. This means that they knew what they were doing was wrong at the time of doing it, however, it mattered to them who they were doing it to. All this, reeks of a moment of moral awakening and suggests a sense of empathy that transcends their original act of theft.
The simple letter conveys a sense of emotional and ethical responsibility, showing a regard for self-reflection and conscience that led to a reversal of said theft. It means that the thieves weighed their personal needs against those of the organization or their victims, decided it in favor of the other party against their self-interest, and then showcased their potential for redemption by actually returning the goods. This clearly shows that there is a path to rehabilitation for those who have strayed into criminal behavior.
But this raises some interesting questions about the nature of morality and empathy. Are these concepts inherent to us, or are they a consequence of our environments and experiences?
The above scenario would suggest that empathy can have actionable effect on us even in the unlikeliest of circumstances, driven by acute awareness of the harm caused to others.
Survival vs. Morality
Whenever I am contemplating such dilemmas, I love to ponder upon the different scenarios where I think about what I would do if I were in their shoes. It is easy to pass judgement on someone from our comfortable sofas and armchairs, but it becomes really gritty when the decisions of ethics and morality come to haunt us in our daily lives.
It often appears such an easy decision to do the right thing, doesn’t it? “Oh, no way I would ever steal from a charity organization.” But it’s a completely different situation when the decision decides whether your children go to bed hungry tonight or not. As previously mentioned, the burglars decided that their personal needs were less important than the victims’. So much so that they decided to act on it despite the personal risk, returning the stolen property, and showing great potential for moral growth and redemption.
Would you, under similar circumstances, make the same choice?
This question compels me to confront my values and rethink how much of these values are shaped by my current circumstances. It makes me think how I can change these circumstances to change my values and vice versa, how this applies to societal notions, and what it says about crime and other values in our society.
![](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F41017efa-deda-48ba-b976-533234f5aa8f_700x467.jpeg)
Reflection of a Society
Reflecting on all this makes me conscious to the deeper societal issues at play. It reveals to me how socio-economic disparities can impact individual behavior and the moral dilemmas that are rooted in systemic inequalities.
It is no secret that our society celebrates the wealthy and conventionally successful ones, while marginalizing those who struggle with these false ideals. Thus, creating a cycle of desperation for climbing a ladder with no end that encourages taking short cuts at every step. If this isn’t a preamble for criminal behavior, I don’t know what is! Circling back to our scenario, even the burglars’ train of thought concluded that we need a more just, equitable and compassionate society. Hence, the act of returning the stuff.
Now this further begets the question of how to fix these systemic issues to address the roots of criminal behavior. Due to the complexity of our social structures, the answer may be also be riddled with complexities. However, we could definitely start approaching these issues through a multipronged approach of perpetually improving economic, educational, and social support systems.
It means empowering systems and flourishing an environment where people are not forced to resort to acts of thievery and robbery. It means working to build a society where empathy, morality, and the sanctity of human life take precedence over material gains. And it means, we focus on structural and systemic changes that drive out acts of desperation and criminal behavior.
Empathy and Redemption
This whole article has been revolving around a story of empathy and the potential for redemption. It has made me peer through the translucent shroud of criminal behavior and reconsider the deeper meaning behind people’s actions and the undercurrents of desperation that drive them to acts of moral wrongdoing. It has inspired me to lift my belief in the beauty of morality amid chaos and use it to build a harmonious society that lifts every individual for their inherent worth; regardless of their social status.
This beautiful concept turn empathy from an individual virtue to a societal one. It connects all our lives through a shared thread of humanity, tied together in knots of social harmony and well-being. It makes us transform our culture into one of peace, compassion, and community.
So, the next you hear about a crime or see someone destitute, I urge you to peak through the shroud as well and choose empathy over judgment, understanding over condemnation, and compassion over condescension.
Because, in the end, we are all human. We are all capable of making mistakes. And we are all capable of making amends.
![](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F309ddbfc-b6d6-481b-8441-7eb76a8d0e86_700x467.jpeg)
March Towards a Just Society
I was almost about to publish this piece when I realized that it would make a world of a difference to talk a little about our march toward a more just and equitable society in pragmatic terms. Staying true to our theme here, the two most prominent areas we see that need to be reevaluated in order to make opportunities and resources more accessible are our justice and economic policies.
We are all much too familiar with the economic drivers that encourage immoral behaviors and, therefore, need to be comprehensively and urgently addressed to mitigate criminal acts. This can include progressive taxation, social safety nets, and investment in education and job training programs. These reforms would lead to a more equitable distribution of wealth, which in turn, leads to a lower number of destitute people, and, therefore, lower incentives to commit a crime.
In terms of our criminal justice system, I have always preached that we need reforms to shift our focus from a retributive justice system to one more focused on rehabilitation and restoration. We need to be more focused on proactive, preventive measures than retrospective action. This story might be one of many where a criminal has a change of heart, and a justice system that prioritizes rehabilitation over retribution may help more people reintegrate into society and reduce recidivism.
The Human Capacity for Change
More than anything, this whole article has been about the human capacity for change. The theme that binds all of it together has consistently been empathy and the potential for redemption. And this whole conversation was about the facilitation of a system that nurtures and encourages the realization of this potential.
We are all products of our environments, molded by our experiences and circumstances. And so, we can help to improve each other’s experiences and circumstances to realize our potential for positive change by cultivating a culture of empathy and understanding that encourages ethical behavior and provides opportunities for personal growth.
This story of the burglars really did spiral me down into a rabbit hole of deep thought and contemplation. It was a rollercoaster through the spectrum of the human condition, flowing through the ups and downs of our societal structures, foundations of criminal behavior, and the potential for empathy and redemption.
But thinking through it all, I believe we can still create a world where we all can thrive together in harmony. We can still build a more compassionate and equitable society where desperation becomes a rare commodity, crumbled under the weight of a transformed, uplifting human condition.
![](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F96bc2783-a986-4d8a-a5c3-a2e2a05cc4f1_700x933.jpeg)